In abhidhamma.-
There are 4 type of minds:
His bad behavior is 1st, 2nd, and 4th mind. Just 3rd mind and a cyst organ are kamma's fruit.
So, the cyst organ is not a main cause of bad behavior. But previous bad behavior is the main cause of present bad behavior.
The cyst organ is just a fruit of the past bad behavior. It maybe one of side cause, but it is not the main cause. A human maybe feel very hurt and hard to decide to make arising of wholesome mind or unwholesome mind because of hurt at body-sense at 4th step but the decision is the 6th step. So, the 7th step is done by his decision in 6th step, not by kamma.
In the other hand: many example in tipitaka and commentary shown that there were many arahanta who were suffered at body-sense, but no one of arahanta have unwholesome-kamma, bad behavior.
There are 4 type of minds:
- wholesome-root functional mind, good kamma.
- unwholesome-root functional mind, bad kamma.
- root's effect functional mind, kamma's fruit.
- rootless functional mind, neither kamma nor fruit.
- human born just by wholesome kamma, but some organ, i.e. cyst, can arise by unwholesome kamma after born.
- kamma has making body-sense for touching touch.
- contact of 3 dhātu: 1) touch arise & 2) body-sense arise & 3) 4th mind arise for to decide the kind of 3th mind, wholesome-effect/unwholesome-effect, that compatible with that touch (same time).
- then 3rd mind knows that touch at body-sense, both are arose by kamma-cause.
- then another 3rd minds know that touch by kamma-cause 2 times.
- then touch is reached by 4th mind again for to decide the kind of 1st, 2nd, or 4th minds should arise to do new kamma in body.
- then 7 times arising of 1st or 2nd mind and do new kamma.
- then 2 times arising of 3rd minds.
- then body vanished.
- Above mind process, at body sense, can loop moreover trillion times per second, uncountable. There are more types of mind process than I show in this answer, this is just the example.
His bad behavior is 1st, 2nd, and 4th mind. Just 3rd mind and a cyst organ are kamma's fruit.
So, the cyst organ is not a main cause of bad behavior. But previous bad behavior is the main cause of present bad behavior.
The cyst organ is just a fruit of the past bad behavior. It maybe one of side cause, but it is not the main cause. A human maybe feel very hurt and hard to decide to make arising of wholesome mind or unwholesome mind because of hurt at body-sense at 4th step but the decision is the 6th step. So, the 7th step is done by his decision in 6th step, not by kamma.
In the other hand: many example in tipitaka and commentary shown that there were many arahanta who were suffered at body-sense, but no one of arahanta have unwholesome-kamma, bad behavior.
No comments:
Post a Comment